| 6/11/1996 | Tropic of Cancer | Henry Miller | Jay | |
| 7/9/1996 | 158 Pound Marriage | John Irving | Naama | |
| 8/13/1996 | Angle of Repose | Wallace Stegner | Jay | Nicole |
| 9/10/1996 | The Moviegoer | Walker Percy | Becky (?) | Becky |
| 10/14/1996 | Silas Marner | George Eliot | Jay | Susan |
| 11/11/1996 | Borderliners | Peter Hoeg | Nicole | Andrew |
| 12/10/1996 | The Human Factor | Graham Greene | Jay | Jay |
| 1/14/1997 | Pnin | Vladimir Nabokov | Andrew | Willy |
| 2/18/1997 | Obasan | Joy Kogawa | Nicole | |
| 3/12/1997 | Ask the Dust | John Fante | Becky | Bubba |
| 4/16/1997 | The Master and Margarita | Mikhail Bulgakov | Nicole | Naama |
| 5/14/1997 | A Parrot in the Oven | Victor Martinez | Andrew | Susan |
| 6/17/1997 | A Map of the World | Jane Hamilton | Becky | |
| 7/9/1997 | The Gift Nobody Wants | Paul Brand | Andrew | Andrew |
| 8/13/1997 | Angela's Ashes | Frank McCort | Becky | Jay |
| 9/3/1997 | Tar Baby | Toni Morrison | Willy | |
| 10/15/1997 | Martin Dressler | Steven Milhauser | Jay | Bubba |
| 10/29/1997 | Hadji Murad | Leo Tolstoy | Nicole | |
| 12/4/1997 | Last Orders | Graham Swift | Andrew | Susan |
| 1/6/1998 | Notes from Underground | Fyodor Dostoevsky | Becky | Fred |
| 2/5/1998 | White Noise | Don Delilo | Andrew | Becky |
| 3/17/1998 | Possession | A.S. Byatt | Jay | |
| 4/9/1998 | Homo Faber | Max Frisch | Nicole | Andrew |
| 5/12/1998 | Pale View of Hills | Kazuo Ishigura | Nicole | Nicole |
| 6/16/1998 | Flesh and Blood | Francois Mauriac | Jay | Bubba |
| 7/14/1998 | Zorba the Greek | Nikos Kazantzakis | Jay | Fred |
| 8/18/1998 | Cat's Eye | Margaret Atwood | Fred | Susan |
| 9/16/1998 | The Silent Cry | Kenzaburo Oe | Nicole | Becky |
| 10/26/1998 | The Beach | Alex Garland | Susan | Jay |
| 11/29/1998 | Atticus | Ron Hansen | Bubba | Nicole |
| 1/3/1999 | A Crime in the Neighborhood | Suzanne Berne | Jay | David W. |
| 2/2/1999 | Seize the Day | Saul Bellow | David W. | Lisa |
| 3/10/1999 | Cold Mountain | Charles Frasier | David W. | Andrew |
| 4/6/1999 | The Screwtape Letters | C.S. Lewis | Fred | Becky |
| 5/16/1999 | The Emigrants | W.G. Sebald | Jay | Bubba |
| 6/17/1999 | The Reader | Bernhard Schlink | Lisa | Fred |
| 7/19/1999 | Let It Come Down | Paul Bowles | Fred | Jay |
| 8/16/1999 | Summer of Betrayal | Hong Ying | Maria | Nicole/Ari |
| 9/20/1999 | The Blue Flower | Penelope Fitzgerald | Bubba | David W. |
| 10/20/1999 | The Woman in the Dunes | Kobo Abe | Nicole | Julia |
| 11/29/1999 | The Immoralist | Andr� Gide | Jay | Maria |
| 12/20/1999 | The Child in Time | Ian McEwan | Jay | Dave L. |
| 1/24/2000 | Quarantine | Jim Crace | Fred | Bubba |
| 2/29/2000 | Cat and Mouse | Gunter Grass | Bubba | Jay |
| 3/20/2000 | Baltasar and Blimunda | Jos� Saramago | Jay | Nicole |
| 4/17/2000 | Dreamers | Knut Hamsen | Julia | Dave W. |
| 5/15/2000 | An Experiment in Love | Hilary Mantel | Julia | Julia |
| 6/19/2000 | Martin and John | Dale Peck | Jay | Maria |
| 7/19/2000 | Identity | Milan Kundera | Julia | Bubba |
| 8/6/2000 | Light Years | James Salter | Jay | Lisa |
| 8/28/2000 | The Anatomist | Federico Andahazi | Nicole | Julia |
| 9/18/2000 | The Archivist | Martha Colley | Jay | Jay |
| 10/19/2000 | The Dwarf | Per Lagerkvist | David | Nicole |
| 11/6/2000 | Too Loud a Solitude | Bohumil Hrabal | Jay | Jay |
| 12/3/2000 | Cannery Row | John Steinbeck | Nicole | Julie |
| 1/8/2001 | Go Tell in on the Mountain | James Baldwin | Julia | Dave W. |
| 2/5/2001 | The Color of Water | James McBride | Jay | Craig |
| 3/12/2001 | Montana 1948 | Larry Watson | Jay | Julia |
| 4/9/2001 | The Odyssey | Homer | Nicole | Bubba |
| 5/6/2001 | Breakfast with Scot | Michael Downing | Julie | |
| 6/4/2001 | Girl with a Pearl Earring | Tracy Chevalier | Dave | Nicole |
| 7/2/2001 | The Puttermesser Papers | Cynthia Ozick | Jay | Dave |
| 8/1/2001 | Across the River and Into the Trees | Ernest Hemingway | Julia | Dave |
| 9/5/2001 | The Pilot's Wife | Anita Shreve | Jay | Lisa |
| 10/10/2001 | Disgrace | J.M. Coetzee | Julia | Julia |
| 11/5/2001 | Motherless Brooklyn | Jonathan Letham | Jay | Jay |
| 12/12/2001 | Norwegian Wood | Haruki Murakami | Jay | Nicole |
| 1/9/2002 | Revolutionary Road | Richard Yates | Scott | Scott |
| 2/4/2002 | The Girl in the Fall-Away Dress | Michelle Richmond | Jay | Mindy |
| 3/11/2002 | Desperate Characters | Paula Fox | Scott | Lisa |
| 4/8/2002 | The Feast of Love | Charles Baxter | Nicole | Alon |
| 5/6/2002 | The Verificationist | Donald Antrim | Jay | Nicole |
| 6/5/2002 | Where You Once Belonged | Kent Haruf | Lisa | Julia |
| 7/1/2002 | Play It As It Lays | Joan Didion | Alon | Jay |
| 8/9/2002 | Fear and Trembling | Amelie Nothomb | Alon | Lisa |
| 9/4/2002 | Portnoy's Complaint | Philip Roth | Alon | Mindy |
| 10/30/2002 | Secrets of the Painter | Matthew Hovious | Lisa | Scott |
| 11/19/2002 | All She Was Worth | Miyuki Miyabe | Jay | Alon |
| 12/16/2002 | Running With Scissors | Augusten Burroughs | Mindy | Nicole |
| 1/14/2003 | The Tartar Steppe | Dino Buzatti | Jay | Julia |
| 2/11/2003 | The MacGuffin | Stanley Elkin | Alon | Jay |
| 3/11/2003 | Harry Gold | Millicent Dillon | Julia | Nicole |
| 4/17/2003 | Thinks | David Lodge | Jay | Julia |
| 5/14/2003 | Middlesex | Jeffrey Eugenides | Lisa | |
| 6/9/2003 | Kitchen | Banana Yoshimoto | Lisa | Mindy |
| 7/20/2003 | My Name Is Red | Orhan Pamuk | Dave | Jeff |
| 8/18/2003 | The Things They Carried | Tim O'Brien | Julia | Nicole |
| 9/8/2003 | Nightwood | Djuna Barnes | Alon | |
| 10/13/2003 | Midwives | Chris Bohjalian | Nicole | Lisa |
| 11/13/2003 | The Da Vinci Code | Dan Brown | Mindy | Julia |
| 12/15/2003 | Lullaby | Chuck Palahniuk | Alon | Jeff |
| 1/14/2004 | Interpreter of Maladies | Jhumpa Lahiri | Lisa | Julia |
| 2/12/2004 | The Book of Illusions | Paul Auster | Jay | Lisa |
| 3/15/2004 | The Devil in the Hills | Cesare Pavese | Alon | Alon |
| 4/26/2004 | The Secret Life of Bees | Sue Monk Kidd | Julia | Jay |
| 5/17/2004 | A Conspiracy of Paper | David Liss | Dave | Heather |
| 7/7/2004 | The Favorite Game | Leonard Cohen | Jay | Nicole |
| 8/2/2004 | Balzac and the Little Chinese Seamstress | Dai Sijie | Jeff | Julia |
| 8/30/2004 | The Man Who Was Thursday | G.K. Chesterton | Julia | Lisa |
| 9/27/2004 | The Moon and Sixpence | W. Somerset Maugham | Jay | Alon |
| 11/1/2004 | The Pornographer's Poem | Michael Turner | Alon | Jay |
| 11/23/2004 | The Piano Teacher | Elfriede Jelinek | Lisa | Bubba |
| 12/13/2004 | The Tennis Players | Lars Gustafsson | Jay | Jennifer |
| 1/18/2005 | The Tortilla Curtain | T.C. Boyle | Jay | Lisa |
| 2/16/2005 | The Jane Austen Book Club | Karen Joy Fowler | Jeff | Vani |
| 3/16/2005 | Pinball | Jerzy Kosinski | Julia | Bubba |
| 4/5/2005 | Rabbit, Run | John Updike | Alon | Jeff |
| 5/11/2005 | Leaving Atlanta | Tayari Jones | Jeff | Julia |
| 6/8/2005 | Jesus Saves | Darcey Steinke | Alon | Dave |
| 7/6/2005 | Oh What a Paradise It Seems | John Cheever | Alon | Jennifer |
| 8/3/2005 | Remembering Laughter | Wallace Stegner | Jennifer | Jeff |
| 9/7/2005 | The Aspern Papers | Henry James | Dave | Bubba |
| 10/5/2005 | The History of Love | Nicole Krauss | Julia | Vani |
| 11/16/2005 | Under the Glacier | Halld�r Laxness | Jay | Alon |
| 12/12/2005 | Never Let Me Go | Kazuo Ishiguro | Jay | Jennifer |
| 1/11/2006 | A Boy's Own Story | Edmund White | Alon | Julia |
| 2/22/2006 | Cloud Atlas | David Mitchell | Dave | Jeff |
| 3/29/2006 | The Dice Man | Luke Rhinehart | Alon | Vani |
| 4/26/2006 | Starting Out in the Evening | Brian Morton | Jay | Mellie Mel |
| 5/17/2006 | Gilead | Marilynne Robinson | Mellie Mel | Bubba |
| 6/8/2006 | The Good Soldier | Ford Madox Ford | Jay | Alon |
| 7/11/2006 | Between the Bridge and the River | Craig Ferguson | Jennifer | Jennifer |
| 8/16/2006 | The Good Mother | Sue Miller | Jay | Julia |
| 9/20/2006 | Appointment in Samarra | John O'Hara | Jeff | Vani |
| 10/18/2006 | Special Topics in Calamity Physics | Marisha Pessl | Mellie Mel | Julia |
| 11/15/2006 | Narcissus and Goldmund | Hermann Hesse | Jay | Jeff |
| 12/13/2006 | The Intuitionist | Colson Whitehead | Alon | Jennifer |
| 1/16/2007 | The Emperor's Children | Claire Messud | Jennifer | Bubba |
| 2/8/2007 | Old School | Tobias Wolff | Jennifer | Mellie Mel |
| 3/7/2007 | The Heart of the Matter | Graham Greene | Jay | Alon |
| 4/19/2007 | The March | E.L. Doctorow | Jeff | Vani |
| 5/16/2007 | The Year of Fog | Michelle Richmond | Julia | Julia |
| 6/19/2007 | The Mystery Guest | Gregoire Bouillier | Vani | Mellie Mel |
| 7/10/2007 | Eve's Ransom | George Gissing | Jeff | Jennifer |
| 8/19/2007 | On Chesil Beach | Ian McEwan | Alon | Bubba |
| 9/19/2007 | Neighbors | Thomas Berger | Jay | Jeff |
| 10/16/2007 | The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao | Junot Diaz | Vani | Vani |
| 11/14/2007 | Summer | Edith Wharton | Mellie Mel | Julia |
| 12/12/2007 | Out Stealing Horses | Per Petterson | Alon | Mellie Mel |
| 1/16/2008 | Ticknor | Sheila Heti | Alon | Jennifer |
| 2/20/2008 | The Keep | Jennifer Egan | Jennifer | Jeff |
| 3/12/2008 | So Long, See You Tomorrow | William Maxwell | Alon | Alon |
| 4/9/2008 | Vernon God Little | DBC Pierre | Bubba | Bubba |
| 5/7/2008 | Brazzaville Beach | William Boyd | Julia | Mellie Mel |
| 6/12/2008 | Stoner | John Williams | Alon | Vani |
| 7/16/2008 | Adolphe | Benjamin Constant | Jay | Jennifer |
| 8/20/2008 | No One You Know | Michelle Richmond | Jay | Jeff |
| 9/24/2008 | An Arsonist's Guide to Writers' Homes in New England | Brock Clarke | Mellie Mel | Julia |
| 11/5/2008 | Madame Bovary & Why Did I Ever |
Gustave Flaubert & Mary Robison |
Mellie Mel & Alon |
Jay |
| 12/3/2008 | Night | Elie Wiesel | Julia | Bubba |
| 1/21/2009 | The Sea, the Sea | Iris Murdoch | Jay | Alon |
| 3/4/2009 | The Dog Star | Donald Windham | Jeff | Vani |
| 4/1/2009 | Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close | Jonathan Safran Foer | Mellie Mel | Mellie Mel |
| 4/29/2009 | Happens Every Day | Isabel Gillies | Jay | Ashley |
| 5/27/2009 | The Elegance of the Hedgehog | Muriel Barbery | Ashley | Jeff |
| 6/24/2009 | The Optimist's Daughter | Eudora Welty | Alon | Greg |
| 7/29/2009 | Elective Affinities | Johann Wolfgang von Goethe | Jeff | Julia |
| 9/2/2009 | A Death in the Family | James Agee | Alon | Bubba |
| 10/7/2009 | Youth in Revolt | C.D. Payne | Vani | Alon |
| 11/11/2009 | Decline and Fall | Evelyn Waugh | Mellie Mel | Jay |
| 12/17/2009 | Time's Arrow | Martin Amis | Greg | Jeff |
| 1/13/2010 | Something To Tell You | Hanif Kureishi | Mellie Mel | Greg |
| 2/17/2010 | Juliet, Naked | Nick Hornby | Jay | Mellie Mel |
| 3/31/2010 | This Must Be the Place | Anna Winger | Julia | Bubba |
| 4/28/2010 | Last Night | James Salter | Jay | Julia |
| 5/26/2010 | Grief | Andrew Holleran | Jay | Jeff |
| 7/14/2010 | The Imperfectionists | Tom Rachman | Greg | Mellie Mel |
| 8/11/2010 | The Eternal Husband | Fyodor Dostoevsky | Alon | Greg |
| 9/22/2010 | The Actual | Saul Bellow | Jay | Alon |
| 10/20/2010 | The Waiting Years | Fumiko Enchi | Jay | Bubba |
| 11/17/2010 | Half a Life | Darin Strauss | Alon | Julia |
| 12/16/2010 | Await Your Reply | Dan Chaon | Jeff | O'ryan |
| 1/13/2011 | Let the Great World Spin | Colum McCann | Mellie | Mellie |
| 2/9/2011 | The Warden | Anthony Trollope | Jay | Jay |
| 3/9/2011 | One Day | David Nicholls | Jay | Jeff |
| 4/13/2011 | Body Surfing | Anita Shreve | Jeff | Greg |
| 5/4/2011 | Alternatives to Sex | Stephen McCauley | Jeff | Julia |
| 6/2/2011 | The Tragedy of Arthur | Arthur Phillips | Greg | Alon |
| 7/13/2011 | City of Thieves | David Benioff | Jeff | Mellie |
| 8/11/2011 | Silence in October | Jens Christian Gr�ndahl | Alon | Julia |
| 9/8/2011 | An Object of Beauty | Steve Martin | Julia | Bubba |
| 10/12/2011 | Pale Fire | Vladimir Nabokov | Alon | Greg |
| 11/9/2011 | Last Night at the Lobster | Stewart O'Nan | Jeff | Jeff |
| 12/1/2011 | The Lost Daughter | Elena Ferrante | Julia | O'ryan |
| 1/18/2012 | The Winter of Our Discontent | John Steinbeck | Jay | Julia |
| 2/22/2012 | Quiet Chaos | Sandro Veronesi | Jay | Greg |
| 3/22/2012 | Smut | Alan Bennett | Alon | Alon |
| 4/18/2012 | The Sense of an Ending | Julian Barnes | Mellie | Mellie |
| 5/16/2012 | Stories of Breece D'J Pancake | Breece D'J Pancake | Julia | Jeff |
| 6/13/2012 | Season of Migration to the North | Tayeb Salih | Alon | Bubba |
| 7/11/2012 | The Lifespan of a Fact | John D'Agata & Jim Fingal | Alon | Jay |
| 8/29/2012 | Swamplandia! | Karen Russell | Mellie | Greg |
| 9/27/2012 | Gone Girl | Gillian Flynn | Mellie | Julia |
| 10/18/2012 | Negative Space | Robert Steiner | Jay | Alon |
| 11/14/2012 | My Hollywood | Mona Simpson | Jay | Jay |
| 12/12/2012 | The Devil in the Flesh | Raymond Radiguet | Jay | O'ryan |
| 1/14/2013 | The Cat's Table | Michael Ondaatje | Jeff | Julia |
| 3/6/2013 | Billy Lynn's Long Halftime Walk | Ben Fountain | Alon | Jay |
| 3/28/2013 | Simple Passion | Annie Ernaux | Jay | Jeff |
| 4/25/2013 | How To Get into the Twin Palms | Karolina Waclawiak | Alon | Bubba |
| 5/22/2013 | The Light Between Oceans | M.L. Stedman | Julia | Julia |
| 6/17/2013 | All That Is | James Salter | Jay | Jay |
| 7/21/2013 | Beautiful Ruins | Jess Walter | Lindsey | O'ryan |
| 8/21/2013 | Anagrams | Lorrie Moore | Jeff | Lindsey |
| 9/19/2013 | The Testament of Mary | Colm Toibin | Jeff | Mellie |
| 10/16/2013 | Where'd You Go, Bernadette | Maria Semple | Jay | Bubba |
| 11/13/2013 | The Privileges | Jonathan Dee | Jeff | Julia |
| 12/11/2013 | Last of the Old Guard | Louis Auchincloss | Jeff | Alon |
| 1/15/2014 | One Last Thing Before I Go | Jonathan Tropper | O'ryan | Jeff |
| 2/13/2014 | The Red House | Mark Haddon | Jeff | Lindsey |
| 3/12/2014 | Mike Tyson Slept Here | Chris Huntington | Alon | Jay |
| 4/9/2014 | Golden State | Michelle Richmond | Jay | Julia |
| 5/15/2014 | Ocean at the End of the Lane | Neil Gaiman | Lindsey | Bubba |
| 6/19/2014 | Twilight | William Gay | Jeff | Alon |
| 7/23/2014 | The Fault in Our Stars | John Green | Julia | Jay |
| 8/27/2014 | Dept. of Speculation | Jenny Offill | Jay/Alon | Lindsey |
| 9/17/2014 | The Furies | Natalie Haynes | Lindsey | Julia |
| 10/15/2014 | Agostino | Alberto Moravia | Alon | Bubba |
| 11/13/2014 | Inquisitor's Diary | Jeffrey Lewis | Jeff | Alon |
| 12/10/2014 | To Rise Again at a Decent Hour | Joshua Ferris | Lindsey | Julia |
| 1/14/2015 | Missing Person | Patrick Modiano | Jay | O'ryan |
| 2/11/2015 | The First Bad Man | Miranda July | Alon | Lindsey |
| 3/11/2015 | Euphoria | Lily King | Jeff | Julia |
| 4/8/2015 | Dear Committee Members | Julie Schumacher | Jay | Bubba |
| 5/6/2015 | Wolf in White Van | John Darnielle | O'ryan | Julia |
| 6/10/2015 | The Hen Who Dreamed She Could Fly | Sun-Mi Hwang | Alon | O'ryan |
| 7/15/2015 | The Queen's Gambit | Walter Tevis | Julia | Julia |
| 8/16/2015 | The Children Act | Ian McEwan | Jay | Lindsey |
| 9/17/2015 | The Martian | Andy Weir | Lindsey | Bubba |
| 10/14/2015 | West of Sunset | Stewart O'Nan | Jeff | Julia |
| 11/11/2015 | On Such a Full Sea | Chang-rae Lee | Lindsey | Alon |
| 12/16/2015 | Lillian on Life | Alison Jean Lester | Julia | Jeff |
| 1/13/2016 | Turtle Diary | Russell Hoban | Julia | Julia |
| 2/10/2016 | The House on the Beach | Juan Garcia Ponce | Jay | Lindsey |
| 3/6/2016 | The Thoughts and Happenings of Wilfred Price Purveyor of Superior Funerals | Wendy Jones | Jeff | O'ryan |
| 4/20/2016 | Station Eleven | Emily St. John Mandel | Mike | Bubba |
| 5/25/2016 | A Coffin for Dimitrios | Eric Ambler | Julia | Julia |
| 6/26/2016 | My Abandonment | Peter Rock | Alon | O'ryan |
| 7/21/2016 | The Girls | Emma Cline | Lindsey | Lindsey |
| 8/17/2016 | The Life and Death of Sophie Stark | Anna North | Jeff | Alon |
| 9/21/2016 | The North Water | Ian McGuire | Alon | Jeff |
| 10/19/2016 | Boy, Snow, Bird | Helen Oyeyemi | Lindsey | Lauren |
| 11/13/2016 | Fates and Furies | Lauren Groff | O'ryan | O'ryan |
| 12/18/2016 | A Man Called Ove | Fredrik Backman | Alon | Alon |
| 1/18/2017 | His Bloody Project | Graeme Macrae Burnet | Lindsey | Lindsey |
| 2/19/2017 | Dark Matter | Blake Crouch | O'ryan | Lauren |
| 3/15/2017 | A Hundred Thousand Worlds | Bob Proehl | Mike | Alon |
| 4/19/2017 | Loving Day | Mat Johnson | Jeff | Jeff |
| 5/17/2017 | Exit West | Moshin Hamid | Lindsey | O'ryan |
| 6/21/2017 | Hillbilly Elegy | J.D. Vance | Josephine | Lindsey |
| 7/26/2017 | Mothering Sunday | Graham Swift | Jeff | Josephine |
| 8/24/2017 | Kitchens of the Great Midwest | J. Ryan Stradal | Jeff | Lauren |
| 9/21/2017 | The Last Days of California | Mary Miller | Jeff | Jeff |
| 10/19/2017 | All the Missing Girls | Megan Miranda | Lauren | Lindsey |
| 11/15/2017 | Sourdough | Robin Sloan | Alon | Alon |
| 12/13/2017 | The Postmortal | Drew Magary | Lauren | Josephine |
| 1/10/2018 | Bluebird, Bluebird | Attica Locke | Alon | Lauren |
| 2/7/2018 | The Immortalists | Chloe Benjamin | O'ryan | Kelly |
| 3/7/2018 | The Hate U Give | Angie Thomas | Lindsey | Jeff |
| 4/5/2018 | The Last Equation of Isaac Severy | Nova Jacobs | Lindsey | Lindsey |
| 5/10/2018 | We Have Always Lived in the Castle | Shirley Jackson | Alon | Alon |
| 6/8/2018 | Pages for You | Sylvia Brownrigg | Jeff | Lauren |
| 7/15/2018 | The Power | Naomi Alderman | Lindsey | Mike |
| 8/15/2018 | Convenience Store Woman | Sayaka Murata | Alon | Kelly |
| 9/16/2018 | Girl in Snow | Danya Kukafka | O'ryan | Lindsey |
| 10/14/2018 | Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine | Gail Honeyman | Mike | Jeff |
| 11/11/2018 | Less | Andrew Sean Greer | O'ryan | Lauren |
| 12/16/2018 | The Wall | Marlen Haushofer | Alon | Alon |
| 1/12/2019 | Little Fires Everywhere | Celeste Ng | Lauren | O'ryan |
| 2/10/2019 | My Sister, the Serial Killer | Oyinkan Braithwaite | Lindsey | Lindsey |
| 3/17/2019 | Where the Crawdads Sing | Delia Owens | Lauren | Jeff |
| 4/14/2019 | Gingerbread | Helen Oyeyemi | O'ryan | O'ryan |
| 5/15/2019 | The Wangs vs. the World | Jade Chang | Mike | Kelly |
| 6/23/2019 | Improvement | Joan Silber | Alon | Lauren |
| 8/4/2019 | My Year of Rest and Relaxation | Ottessa Moshfegh | Lindsey | Alon |
| 9/22/2019 | Who Is Vera Kelly? | Rosalie Knecht | Jeff | O'ryan |
| 10/13/2019 | Drive Your Plow Over the Bones of the Dead | Olga Tokarczuk | Alon | Lindsey |
| 11/10/2019 | They Both Die at the End | Adam Silvera | Mike | Kelly |
| 12/15/2019 | This Is How You Lose the Time War | Amal El-Mohtar and Max Gladstone | Lindsey | Lauren |
| 1/19/2020 | Severance | Ling Ma | Alon | O'ryan |
| 2/23/2020 | Recursion | Blake Crouch | Lauren | Alon |
| 5/30/2021 | I, Tituba, Black Witch of Salem | Maryse Conde | Alon | Lindsey |
| 7/11/2021 | While Justice Sleeps | Stacey Abrams | Alon | Kelly |
| 8/16/2021 | No One Is Talking About This | Patricia Lockwood | Lindsey | Jeff |
| 9/19/2021 | There There | Tommy Orange | Jeff | Lauren |
| 10/24/2021 | The Final Girl Support Group | Grady Hendrix | Lauren | O'ryan |
| 11/14/2021 | Heaven, My Home | Attica Locke | Jeff | Alon |
| 12/12/2021 | Outlawed | Anna North | Lindsey | Lindsey |
| 1/16/2022 | The Friend | Sigrid Nunez | Jeff | Jeff |
| 2/20/2022 | Klara and the Sun | Kazuo Ishiguro | Lindsey | Lauren |
| 3/20/2022 | Another Brooklyn | Jacqueline Woodson | Alon | O'ryan |
| 4/24/2022 | We Run the Tides | Vendela Vida | Sarah | Sarah |
| 6/26/2022 | The Maid | Nita Prose | Lindsey | Alon |
| 8/6/2022 | Goodbye, Vitamin | Rachel Khong | Alon | Sarah |
| 9/17/2022 | Wildcat | Amelia Morris | Alon | Lindsey |
| 10/8/2022 | Cult Classic | Sloane Crosley | Lindsey | Lauren |
| 11/19/2022 | Movie Star by Lizzie Pepper | Hilary Liftin | Jeff | Jeff |
| 12/4/2022 | The Chosen and the Beautiful | Nghi Vo | Sarah | Mike |
| 1/14/2023 | Saturday Night Ghost Club | Craig Davidson | Lauren | Lindsey |
| 2/11/2023 | Before the Coffee Gets Cold | Toshikazu Kawaguchi | Lindsey | Alon |
| 3/19/2023 | The Candy House | Jennifer Egan | Sarah B | Sarah W |
| 4/23/2023 | Under the Whispering Door | TJ Klune | Mike | O'ryan |
| 5/28/2023 | Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow | Gabrielle Zevin | Jeff | Lauren |
| 6/25/2023 | Willful Disregard | Lena Andersson | Jeff | Jeff |
| 7/20/2023 | Bear | Marian Engel | Alon | Sarah B |
| 8/16/2023 | Trust | Hernan Diaz | Sarah W | Sarah W |
| 9/24/2023 | Love Marriage | Monica Ali | Sarah B | Lindsey |
| 10/15/2023 | I Have Some Questions for You | Rebecca Makkai | Sarah W | Alon |
| 11/12/2023 | Piranesi | Susanna Clarke | Lindsey | Lauren |
| 12/17/2023 | Y/N | Esther Yi | Alon | Sarah B |
| 1/21/2024 | Want | Lynn Steger Strong | Sarah W | Sarah W |
| 2/18/2024 | Remarkably Bright Creatures | Shelby Van Pelt | Sarah W | Jeff |
| 3/17/2024 | Acts of Service | Lillian Fishman | Jeff | O'ryan |
| 4/28/2024 | Matrix | Lauren Groff | Sarah B | Lindsey |
| 5/19/2024 | Martyr! | Kaveh Akbar | Lauren | Alon |
| 6/9/2024 | The Morningside | Téa Obreht | Lindsey | Lauren |
| 7/14/2024 | Anxious People | Fredrik Backman | O'ryan | Jeff |
| 8/25/2024 | Small Things Like These | Claire Keegan | Lindsey | Sarah W |
| 10/6/2024 | All Fours | Miranda July | Sarah W | Sarah B |
| 11/3/2024 | Diavola | Jennifer Thorne | Lauren | Alon |
| 12/16/2024 | Civilizations | Laurent Binet | O'ryan | Lindsey |
| 2/8/2025 | Banal Nightmare | Halle Butler | Alon | Mike |
| 3/16/2025 | We All Want Impossible Things | Catherine Newman | Alon | Lauren |
| 4/13/2025 | God of the Woods | Liz Moore | Lauren | Sarah B |
| 5/13/2025 | Audition | Katie Kitamura | Sarah B | Jeff |
| 6/29/2025 | Butter | Asako Yuzuki | Alon | Lindsey |
| 7/26/2025 | Witchcraft for Wayward Girls | Grady Hendrix | Lauren | Mike |
| 8/25/2025 | Make Sure You Die Screaming | Zee Carlstrom | Mike | Alon |
| 9/21/2025 | Kindred | Octavia Butler | Lindsey | Lauren |
| 10/19/2025 | Bury Your Gays | Chuck Tingle | Lauren | Sarah B |
| 11/9/2025 | I Love You So Much It's Killing Us Both | Mariah Stovall | Alon | Amanda |
| 12/14/2025 | Wild Dark Shore | Charlotte McConaghy | Amanda | Lindsey |
| 1/11/2025 | Beautyland | Marie-Helene Bertino | Lindsey | Jeff |